Trial Courts Must Use Clear, Definite Language For a Final Judgment to be Valid and Appealable

hammer_court_dollar_dollar-1024x768Every day, individuals rely on the court system to resolve disputes, to ensure due process, and to serve justice. Individuals who are victims of an accident and suffered injury often need the courts to be restored to their previous condition. However, when a court issues an unclear final judgment, you need an excellent attorney to assist in sorting through the confusion and helping you find relief.

Luis Espinoza-Peraza was involved in a car accident and sustained injuries after being rear-ended by a car owned and operated by Martha Alexander and Willard Belton. He brought this lawsuit in November 2012, seeking damages from Belton, Alexander, and their insurer, Allstate. Allstate immediately sought a peremptory exception raising res judicata, meaning there had already been a final judgment on the matter, and could not be re-litigated. According to Allstate, it had previously issued a check to Espinoza-Peraza in relation to the accident, and he cashed the check with full knowledge of it being a final settlement.

Even though the trial court maintained the peremptory exception at a June 2014 hearing, the trial court did not sign the written judgment until January 2016. In the meantime, Espinoza-Peraza had moved for a new trial, but that motion was denied in September 2014. Then, in March 2015, the trial court finally signed a written judgment denying Espinoza-Peraza’s motion for a new trial and dismissed Belton, Alexander, and Allstate from the suit. Espinoza-Peraza then filed an appeal for the permitted peremptory exception and the denial of his motion for a new trial.

The First Circuit Court of Appeal began its discussion in this case by explaining the standard for lower courts in issuing a proper, appealable final judgment. A final judgment must rule on the merits of a dispute and articulate the actual judgment using specific, certain, and appropriate language. It also needs to clearly identify the relief being granted or denied, the party in favor of the ruling, and the party against it. If multiple defendants are involved in the case, the name of the particular defendant “against whom the judgment is rendered” must be indicated on the face of the judgment.

The First Circuit ultimately found that the judgment from January 2016 did not have appropriate “decretal language” since it did not clearly dismiss any party nor appropriately dispose of the claims made by Espinoza-Peraza against the defendants. Because of these omissions, the judgment could not constitute a final judgment and, therefore, cannot be reviewed on appeal.

The Court also addressed how the March 2015 interlocutory judgment, denying Espinoza-Peraza’s motion for a new trial, contained sufficient language in properly dismissing Alexander, Belton, and Allstate from the lawsuit. However, since it was an interlocutory judgment, it can only be appealed when it is considered part of the appeal of the final judgment. Therefore, the Court dismissed the appeal, lacking jurisdiction, because the final judgment was invalid.

The court system is essential, especially for those who have been hurt and deserve adequate compensation to restore them to how they once were. However, there is always the potential for courts to make a mistake, such as issuing a confusing, invalid judgment. If this situation occurs, a seasoned attorney can assist you in the next steps, helping to obtain the damages you deserve.

Additional Sources: Luis Espinoza-Peraza v. Martha Alexander, Willard Belton and Allstate Property and Casualty Insurance Company

Written by Berniard Law Firm Blog Writer: Kate Letkewicz

Additional Berniard Law Firm Articles Involving Insurance Disputes: Louisiana Court excludes coverage for a woman severely injured by an elderly caregiver’s negligent loading of her wheelchair; Insurance Provider Fails to Cancel Customer’s Coverage after Nonpayment, Must Pay Damages.   Appealing a Court Judgment in Louisiana: Why Decretal Language Matters

Contact Information