by

Medical malpractice claims and recovery based on those claims are regulated by Louisiana statute. As such, the law places limits on the time an injured party has to file a claim. Once a claim is filed, the review process is subject to intermediate deadlines. As the following case demonstrates, a misstep in either the overall time limit or one of these intermediate points can be hazardous to a malpractice claim.

The case of Carter v. Ochsner Clinic Foundation, 978 So.2d 562 (La. Ct. App. 2008), involved a plaintiff, Janet Carter, whose mother died because of an improperly placed catheter. Ms. Carter sued both the doctor and the clinic involved in her mother’s treatment. Unfortunately for Ms. Carter, her attorneys’ work also proved to be a little sloppy.

Ms. Carter’s mother passed away on July 14, 2005. Under Louisiana law, a claim for a wrongful death resulting from medical malpractice must be filed within one year of the death (La. Rev. Stat. Ann. § 9:5628). Technically, the law requires a plaintiff to file a claim within one year of the malpractice or one year of discovering malpractice. However, the Louisiana courts have reasoned that when a person dies, the potential malpractice is readily evident. Thus, the statute of limitations begins to run on the date of death.

Continue reading

by

Schools Tackle Prom Drinking Risk

Schools around the country attempt to confront the issue of student drunk driving, especially in the spring around prom season. One way to try to prevent teen drinking and driving is to talk to kids about the dangers while they are still young. Many high schools bring in a speaker, often a family member of someone killed by a drunk driver, or even a sorrowful drunk driver himself. There are also a variety of groups dedicated to educating young people about the dangers of alcohol and automobiles. Groups such as Mothers Against Drunk Driving and even student groups of Students Against Drunk Driving can help spread this message to students.

But a Baldwin high school, West St. Mary, located in St. Mary Parish, chose an even more attention-grabbing method. Instead of an assembly, the school involved students, Baldwin fire rescue workers, St. Mary Parish Sheriff’s deputies, Louisiana State Troopers and even a hearse from a local funeral home to put together a mock car accident.

Continue reading

by

When a person is injured by the poor or defective condition of public property (such as a cracked sidewalk or a pothole in the roadway), he or she may be able to recover from the municipality responsible for maintaining the property. Under Louisiana law, actions in against city governments for require the plaintiff to show the following: (1) the thing that caused the injury to the victim was under the city’s control; (2) the thing was defective due to a condition that created an unreasonable risk of harm to the victim; (3) the city had notice of the defect, yet did not take corrective action within a reasonable period of time; and (4) the defect was a cause in fact of the victim’s injury. LSA-R.S. 9:2800.

Ordinarily, the notice requirement means that someone must have reported the problem to the city (“actual notice”) or the defect must have existed long enough for it to have been discovered as part of the city’s regular maintenance operations (“constructive notice”). This is often a significant hurdle for injured victims, as dangerous conditions are frequently overlooked by the public and the victim generally has no information about whether the condition existed long enough that the city should have discovered the problem.

However, the law provides an alternative:

Continue reading

by

Car accident claims often hinge on whether or not the defendant owed a duty to the injured party. If a duty was owed, it was breached, and the breach caused an injury, liability for negligence exists. However, if there was no duty, the claim is cut off.

The important question is then, when does a duty exist? Generally speaking, people and entities have a duty to act reasonably in every particular circumstance. Reasonableness can be difficult to define and it often depends on the relationship between the parties. For example, a taxi cab driver may have a duty to exercise more care in driving their fares than someone dropping a friend off at work. Sometimes state or federal laws and regulations help to define when a duty exists. If a party has violated a legally defined duty, bringing a successful negligence claim against them may be easier.

One such instance of a legally defined duty applies to those that operate commercial vehicles. According to Regulations issued by the U.S. Department of Transportation’s Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration, “extreme caution” must be taken when commercial vehicle drivers find themselves in treacherous road conditions.

Continue reading

by

Most parents probably get a little nervous when their teens take to the road, and for good reason. Teenage drivers are often very dangerous behind the wheel. In addition to their inexperience, teen drivers are more likely to succumb to the supposed “thrill” of risky behaviors like drunk driving, driving at night, distracted driving due to cell phones or usage of MP3 players, etc.

Statistics confirm parental apprehension. According to one insurance provider, each year:

More than 400,000 teens between 16 and 20 are severely injured in car accidents, and more than 5,000 lose their lives. Despite the very small percentage (10%) of the population that teenagers account for, teenage car crashes actually account for 12 percent of fatal car accidents.

Continue reading

by

In 2005, Dale Spires of DeRidder was in a car accident that was caused by April Roberts. He sued Ms. Roberts and her insurance company paid out $10,000, which was the limit under her insurance policy. The suit was dismissed in 2006.

In 2007, Spires filed an additional lawsuit against his uninsured motorist carrier, State Farm, and alleged that Ms. Roberts was underinsured and as such he was entitled to additional recovery for the damages he sustained in the accident as well as for his emotional distress. State Farm argued that under Louisiana law, Spires had to assert all causes of action in the first suit against Ms. Roberts and was precluded from collection additional damages from state farm since the action arises from the same accident. As such, Stare Farm argued, because Spires did not bring the claim against State Farm when he sued Ms. Roberts he could no longer do so. The trial court agreed and dismissed the claim, leading to the Spires appeal.

In a 2008 decision, the Court of Appeals reversed the trial court judgment and found that the Spires were entitled to pursue a claim against State Farm for additional damages. The case hinged on the court’s interpretation of La.Code Civ.p. art 425 which states, “A party shall assert all causes of action arising out of the transaction or occurrence that is the subject matter of the litigation.” According to the Court, art. 425 is merely a reference to the broader principle of res judicata.

Continue reading

by

The cruise ship Celebrity Mercury was forced to its home port of Charleston for a four day cleaning recently. After the third straight outbreak of Norovirus on the 1870 passenger ship, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control issued a rare “no sail” recommendation. The return home came after Celebrity took some action to stem the outbreak to no avail.

As noted in an article in USA Today,

The repeated outbreaks came despite an aggressive effort by the line to stop the chain of transmission of the illness. Celebrity conducted an unusual top-to-bottom cleaning of the Mercury Feb. 26-27 that delayed the ship’s Feb. 26 departure by a day. The line also delayed the March 8 departure of the ship by several hours so it could undergo another round of extra cleaning and disinfecting

Continue reading

by

On Friday, March 19, a police checkpoint in north LeFourche surveyed over 200 cars on La. 20 in Chackbay between 10 p.m. and 4a.m. according to a Daily Comet article. The checkpoint caught three DWI offenders and cited nine open-container violations.

Sobriety checkpoints are legal in the state of Louisiana. Many residents see being stopped momentarily by the police as a small inconvenience to endure in order to deter alcohol impaired driving. The state of Louisiana employs many aggressive drunk-driving policies. Louisiana requires an ignition interlock for all first time DWI offenders and has strict policies for parents and other persons contributing to the intoxication of minors.

Despite Louisiana’s tough policies when it comes to drunk driving, according to the National Center for Statistical Analysis, 37% of traffic fatalities in Louisiana were alcohol related in 2007.

Continue reading

by

Reports of drivers arrested for DWI, or “driving while intoxicated,” should serve as a reminder of the substantial duty imposed by the law on drivers to operate their vehicles in a safe manner. Motor vehicle operators owe a duty of care to all other drivers, passengers, and pedestrians to take reasonable care to avoid harm or injury. Some common breaches of this duty include driving too fast for conditions, failing to keep a proper lookout for other traffic, failing to observe traffic signals or markings, and driving while impaired by alcohol or drugs.

Two recent reports from Houma Today involve drivers who operated their vehicles while “under the influence” in Terrebonne Parish. The first involved Jeffrey Trahan of Gibson, Louisiana, who on March 22 received a five-year prison sentence for his role in a deadly car crash one year prior. According to police, on March 22, 2009, Trahan drove his 1996 Honda Accord on North Bayou Black Drive in Houma where he ran off the road into a ditch. Trahan’s car flipped over, ejecting both Trahan and Donald McInnis, his passenger. McInnis, 17, who was also from Gibson, was pronounced dead at the scene of the accident. According to prosecutor Juan Pickett, Trahan tested positive for marijuana and Xanax, a prescription anti-anxiety medication that can adversely affect driving. Trahan pleaded guilty to vehicular homicide and will be required to serve at least three years in jail without parole.

In the second report, James McDowell III of Baton Rouge was arrested in Thibodaux on March 24 for a fifth-offense DWI. At approximately 1:30 AM, a Louisiana state trooper observed McDowell swerving across lanes on La. Hwy. 308 near Bubba’s II Seafood Restaurant. The trooper charged McDowell with improper lane use, driving with a suspended license, and having an open container of alcohol in his car. McDowell had a blood-alcohol content of .052. While the state legal limit is .08, the trooper arrested McDowell because he had reason to believe that McDowell might have been under the influence of another substance. McDowell was taken to the Lafourche Parish jail.

Continue reading
Contact Information
1140 St Charles Ave
New Orleans, LA 70130
Phone: (504) 521-6000
Fax: (504) 617-6300

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Please do not include any confidential or sensitive information in a contact form, text message, or voicemail. The contact form sends information by non-encrypted email, which is not secure. Submitting a contact form, sending a text message, making a phone call, or leaving a voicemail does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Copyright © 2016 – 2025, Berniard Law Firm
JUSTIA Law Firm Blog Design