Articles Posted in Litigation

On January 22nd a state court jury found in favor of 84 year old Berna Courville in her suit against Robinswood School (on the former Chennault Air Force Base). Ms. Courville’s son, 39 year old Tony Courville, had been a resident of the facility that cares for people with severe mental retardation for the past 15 years.

According to the Courville family, they noticed their son coughing on June 5-6, 2005. They notified the facility who they allege did not treat the cough. Courville was taken to the hospital with pneumonia on June 14, 2005. His chest was so full of fluid that his heart and trachea had been shoved over. According to the testimony of pulmonologist Dr. Gary Kohler, 4.5 liters were drained from the right side of his chest. Per medical records, Robinswood allowed Courville to gain 41 pounds in 14 days. He did not recover from the pneumonia and eventually passed away.

Courville’s untimely death led his surviving family members to file suit against the facility, alleging they acted improperly and negligently in their care for the man. While Courville’s family believed the death was the result of what should have been an obvious illness that medical caregivers would detect under proper conditions, Robinswood alleged in court that this was not the case and that the care the facility provided was proper.

The Crowley Today reports that a man has filed suit against a Arcadia Parish Sheriff’s Deputy, the Crowley Police Department, and the City after an incident that occurred less than one year ago on July 16, 2009.

The suit concerns Reginald Phillips, an Arcadia man who merely wanted to return to his estranged wife’s residence to retrieve his belongings. Fearing his estranged wife might resort to violence during this visit, Mr. Phillips requested Crowley Police escort him on his trip. Mr. Phillips alleges that while inside her residence, the officers left him and his wife alone. It was at this point that Kimberly Phillips allegedly shot Mr. Phillips several times, resulting in severe injuries including permanent paralysis below the waist.

Mr. Phillips alleges in his claim general negligence against the officers and the Police Department. Case history in Louisiana has shown that prevailing on a statutory negligence claim under Louisiana Civil Code Articles 2315 and 2316, plaintiffs are required to allege five elements: (1) the defendant had a duty owed to the plaintiff to exhibit a specific minimum level of conduct; (2) the defendant breached his duty to live up to this standard; (3) the defendant’s conduct actually caused the plaintiff’s injuries; (4) the defendant’s conduct could in some way serve as the legal basis